For a further week Isabelle and Stephen lived their strange existence in the boulevard du Gange, going through the daily rituals of normal behaviour even though their minds existed elsewhere. Each noticed, with admiration and some misgiving, how easily the other was able to pretend.
Stephen found that their hurried and clandestine couplings were made more powerful to him by their element of fear. They made love where they could: in the red room, in temporarily deserted sitting rooms, on the grassy bank at the foot of the garden. The urgency of limited time removed all inhibitions.
He did not pause to think. His mind was disarrayed by passion. It had become capable of only one desire or thought: that things should continue. The calm nature of his public behaviour was given to him by this imperative.
Isabelle was bemused by the power of the physical life that had suddenly opened up in her and found equal excitement in their fast and dangerous exchanges. But she missed the intimacy of conversation that they had first had in the red room; this seemed to her as delicate an act of closeness as any physical touch they had yet discovered.
One day, following a whispered consultation in the hall, Stephen contrived to come back from the factory early when Isabelle had dispatched Marguerite and Lisette for the afternoon.
He found her already waiting for him in the red room. Afterward, as he sat back against the pillows, he stared at the picture of a medieval knight above the mantelpiece. In the grate there was a fire laid with neatly chopped kindling and coal. On the far wall was a large country wardrobe in which were stored unused curtains, rugs, winter coats, and various vases, clocks, and boxes with no place in the house. The wood of the window frame was stripped and unpainted. Some white flowers of clematis moved in a light breeze against the glass.
It was the first chance Stephen had had since their excursion to the river to tell Isabelle about Lisette. In the reckless trust of his passion he told her everything, expecting her to value his honesty above any meaner feeling of unease. Isabelle seemed curious.
“I don’t understand where she could have learned about these things.”
“I suppose she’s older than we thought. Didn’t you feel such things at that age?”
Isabelle shook her head. “Jeanne had told me what would happen one day, but I had no feelings of desire, not in the way you describe in Lisette.”
“I think she feels the loss of her mother. She wants attention.”
“Was she excited? Was she… I don’t know how to ask.”
“You mean would she be ready to make love to a man?”
“Yes.”
“Yes, she would be ready as a woman, in her body, but she would almost certainly choose the wrong man.”
“You.”
“Or worse.”
Isabelle shook her head. “Poor Lisette.”
She looked over at him. She said, “Did you want to… with her?”
“No. For a moment there was a reflex, like an animal. But no. I only ever want to do it with you.”
“I don’t believe you.” Isabelle laughed.
Stephen smiled at her. “You’re teasing me, Isabelle.”
“Yes, of course I am.” She ran her hand down his abdomen. “You are wicked,” she whispered in his ear.
Sometimes Stephen felt his body was no more than a channel for exterior powers; it had no proper sense of fatigue or proportion. He thought of Lisette as he lay on top of Isabelle again. He believed Isabelle had found the story of Lisette’s indiscretion in some perverse way arousing.
Later he said, “I am worried that she’ll tell your husband.” Isabelle, who had recovered her composure, said, “I’m more worried that I have a duty to stay and look after her.”
“To stay?”
“Yes. Instead of… “
“Instead of coming with me to England?”
Isabelle, confronted with the thought at last in words, nodded dumbly. Stephen felt a quiet exultation; although he had supplied the words, the idea had been hers.
“But that’s what you will do,” he said. “You will leave the husband who beats you and go with the man who loves you. Lisette is not your child. You’ve already done well by her, you’ve been helpful to her. But you must live your own life eventually. You have one chance only.”
He heard the declamatory note in what he said but did not disown it. He wanted Isabelle to remember the words so that they would count with her when she was alone, making her decision.
“And what would we do in England?” she teased him, not yet willing to think about it properly.
Stephen breathed in slowly. “I’m not sure. We’d go and live somewhere remote, not in London. I would find work in a business of some kind. We would have children.”
This seemed to take the lightness out of Isabelle’s manner. “And Lisette and Grégoire… They would lose another mother.”
“And if you stay you will lose your life.”
“I don’t want to think about it.”
“But you must. I’m supposed to return to London next week. You could come with me. Or we could go away together somewhere in France.”
“Or you could stay and work here in the town. We could meet.”
“Not that, Isabelle. You know that wouldn’t work.”
“I must dress again. I must go downstairs to be ready for when Lisette comes back.”
“Before you go, I want to ask you something. Lucien Lebrun. There was a rumour that you and he… “
“Lucien!” Isabelle laughed. “I like him. I think he’s admirable, but really… “
“I’m sorry. I shouldn’t have asked. It’s just that… I was worried.”
“Don’t worry. Don’t ever worry. There’s only you. Now really I must get dressed.”
“Let me dress you, then.”
He went to fetch her clothes from the chair where she had left them. “Put your foot here and the other one here. Now stand up. And does this come next? How does this fasten? Let me just straighten this. You’re breathing so hard, my love. Was it here that I touched you, was it here?”
Isabelle was half-dressed, half-revealed. She stood holding Stephen’s head as he sank to his knees in front of her.
As she began to sigh again, he stood up in front of her and said, “You will come with me, won’t you?”
Her answer was hissed between closed teeth.
The front door banged as Azaire made his way down the hall with a copy of the evening paper in his hand.
“Isabelle!” he called. “The strike is finished. The dyers return tomorrow.” She appeared at the top of the stairs. “That’s good news.”
“And tomorrow Meyraux will recommend my new terms to the men.”
“I’m very pleased.”
At least it meant Azaire would be in a good mood, she thought; he would not persecute her with words or come to her room later to air his frustration.
“And when will you be leaving us, Monsieur?” said Azaire at dinner, pouring a small measure of wine into Stephen’s glass.
“At the end of the week, as we planned.”
“Good. It has been interesting for us at the factory, as I was saying to you this morning. I hope you’ve enjoyed your time with us.”
“It has been a pleasure to stay with your charming family.” Azaire looked contented. His eyes for once lost their wounded look. The prospect of a return to normal routine in all aspects of his life evidently pleased him. Isabelle saw his relief at Stephen’s imminent departure and the end of the strike, but she could not understand how he could so happily contemplate a resumption of his life as it had been. The way he treated her might, at some stretch of his imagination, be viewed as a painful and provisional transition toward a better feeling, but not as a desirable way of behaviour that he was anxious to begin again. She was not frightened of him, but his attitude depressed her. Winters of loneliness stretched out in front of her; if he was content not to change, then she would find deeper isolation in his presence than in her own.
Meanwhile there was Stephen, an alternative she could not consider with any kind of calmness. There was too much danger in her feeling and in the practical details of what they could do. She felt she might avoid the fallibility of her own judgement by depending on his; though he was younger, he seemed sure of what was right.
Lisette had been subdued since the excursion to the river; she no longer enlivened dinner with sulks or suggestive remarks. She would not catch Stephen’s eye, though he tried to meet hers with some reassurance. She sat in silence over her food as the sound of the clock on the small marble-topped serving table became louder in the room.
“I heard the strangest story,” said Azaire abruptly.
“What was that?” said Isabelle.
“They told me that at the height of the strike someone was visiting little Lucien and was taking him parcels of food to give to the dyers’ families.”
“Yes, I heard that,” said Stephen. “A number of sympathetic people in the town helped the strikers. There was one man in particular who wanted to be anonymous. So I was told at the factory.”
“Oh dear me no,” said Azaire. “This wasn’t a man, this was a woman, “The strikers had help from many sources, I expect.”
“But the strangest thing about this woman was that she was married to the owner of a factory.” Azaire paused and looked round the table. Neither of the children were listening. Isabelle was motionless.
“Now isn’t that a strange thing?” said Azaire raising his glass to his lips. “I couldn’t believe it when I heard it.”
“I don’t think it’s strange,” said Isabelle. “It was me.” Stephen looked at her uncomprehendingly. Azaire replaced his wine glass heavily on the table.
“But my dear–“
“I took them food because they were hungry. I had no idea of whether they should be on strike or not, but I had seen their children asking for bread, running along behind the carts bringing in vegetables to the market. I had seen them going through the dustbins in Saint Leu and I felt sorry for them.”
Isabelle’s voice was surprisingly calm. She said, “I would do the same again, whether the people made cloth or shoes or anything else.”
Azaire was white; his lips were a shade of pale purple as though even this soft membrane had repelled his blood.
“Leave the room,” he said to Lisette. “And you.” Grégoire pushed his chair noisily back on the wooden floor, pausing to take a piece of chicken from his plate.
Azaire stood up. “I discounted these rumours. I did not believe them, even though it was your name that was attached to them and I suppose I should have learned about you by now. However wilful and selfish you are I could not believe that you would ever, ever behave toward me in such a way. And you, Monsieur, you had better leave the room.”
“No. Let him stay.”
“Why? He–“
“Let him stay.”
A look of panic passed over Azaire’s face. He tried to speak, but failed. He drank again from his glass. His imagination seemed to be supplying more appalling possibilities than his previously controlled and teasing anger could admit. He struggled towards the worst question. He began it, “You…?” He looked at Stephen, then down at the table. His courage visibly failed him. He fought with himself, then regained control by resuming his previous manner.
“I did not believe my wife could let me down in such a way. The further reason I would not believe the rumours was that there was another piece of tittletattle that went with them, which said that the lady in question was also… ” He waved his hand, as though swatting the thought “Not with Lucien,” said Isabelle. Azaire’s face seemed to collapse. His voice had so pitifully requested a complete dismissal of the rumour that Isabelle’s partial denial appeared worse than a confirmation of what he feared.
She saw this and moved to end his uncertainty even if she could not stop his anguish. “Not with Lucien. With Stephen.”
Azaire looked up from his seat. “With… him?”
“Yes.” Stephen looked evenly back at him. “With me. I pursued your wife .1 seduced her. You must hate me, not her.”
He wanted to protect Isabelle as far as he could, though he was astounded to find himself in this position: Isabelle could easily have prevaricated. His slow heart was beating hard. He looked at Azaire, whose jaw had gone loose, causing his mouth to open. There was a dribble of wine on his chin. Stephen pictured the misery from the way it affected the muscles of his face. He felt pity for him. Then, in the interests of preserving something for Isabelle and himself, he hardened his heart. It was an act of almost physical willpower, as he compelled the compassion to go out of him.
Isabelle was no longer able to be cold toward Azaire. The brief sentences with which she had informed him of her unfaithfulness seemed to have drained her resolve and she began to weep and to apologize to him for what she had done. Stephen listened carefully to what she said. He did not begrudge Azaire his wife’s apologies but he did not want her to retreat too far.
Azaire was incapable of saying more than “With him? Here?” Isabelle said, “I’m sorry… so sorry, René. I meant you no harm. It is a passion for Stephen. It was not done to hurt you.”
“This… boy, this English boy? In my house? Where? In your bed?”
“It doesn’t matter, René. It doesn’t matter where.”
“It does to me. I want to know. Did you… in which room?”
“For God’s sake,” said Stephen.
Azaire sat silently at the table, his hand still clutching the base of his glass. His mouth dropped open again and he screwed up his eyes in puzzlement, as though looking into a bright sun.
“And your father, Monsieur Fourmentier, what can he do…? What will they say? My God, my God.”
Isabelle looked at Stephen and there was fear in her eyes. Stephen could see that she had not calculated what effect her sudden honesty would have on her husband. The fear was no doubt partly for Azaire’s well-being, but also seemed to be for herself: there was a chance that in the crisis she might lose her resolution and follow some older code of conduct which would compel her to put herself once more at Azaire’s mercy.
It made Stephen feel uneasy as he looked at the wreckage of this suddenly precipitated storm. He felt he needed to keep Isabelle’s determination in place, but this could not be done if Azaire collapsed completely.
He was muttering to himself: “Bitch… Your father told me and I never listened. In my own house. And now my children. What will become of them? Bitch.”
“Listen.” Stephen moved swiftly round the table and took him by the shoulders. “What can you expect from a woman you have treated as you have treated Isabelle? Did you expect her to humiliate herself for your pleasure, to sit meekly at your table in the knowledge that you would beat her later?” Azaire was rejuvenated. “What did you tell him?”
“It doesn’t matter what she told me. This is a house where everything can be heard. How can you sit there and call her names after what you’ve done to her? This is a woman with her own life and feelings and look what you have done to her. What have you _done?” _He pushed Azaire violently back into his chair. Azaire seemed inspired by Stephen’s anger. He stood up and said, “You will leave my house within the hour. If you have any sense you will never let me see you again.”
“Certainly I will leave your house,” said Stephen. “And I am taking your wife with me. Isabelle?”
“I don’t want this.” Isabelle shook her head. The words came from her mouth without thought or calculation in their purity of feeling. “I don’t know what to do or how to behave now. I could be happy in the simplest way, like any other woman with a family of her own, without this terrible pain I’ve caused. I won’t listen to either of you. Why should I? How do I know that you love me, Stephen? How can I tell?” Her voice fell to the low, soft note Stephen had heard when she spoke on his first evening in the house. It was a beautiful sound to his ears: pleading and vulnerable, but with a sense of strength in its own Tightness. “And you, René, why should I trust you when you have given me so little reason even to like you?” Both men watched her in silence. Stephen believed in the strength of feeling between them, and believed it would persuade her.
Isabelle said, “This is not a situation anyone can be prepared for. Nothing I have learned in religion, or from my family or my own thoughts is any help to me. I won’t be painted as some sort of whore by you, René. I’m a frightened woman, no more than that–not an adulterer, or a harlot or anything else. I’m just the same person I ever was, but you never took the trouble to find out what that was.”
“Forgive me, I–“
“Yes, I do forgive you. I forgive you any wrong you’ve done me and I ask you to forgive me the wrong I’ve certainly done to you. I am going upstairs to pack.” She left the room with a rustle of her skirt and a barely discernible trace of roses.
“You go with him,” Azaire shouted after her, “and you are going to hell!” Stephen turned and left the room, trying to still the exultation of his heart. Isabelle placed the framed photograph of Jeanne on top of the clothes she had piled in her case. She paused for a moment, then added the family group with her parents in their Sunday best, Mathilde, dark-haired and womanly on her father’s right hand, herself, a little fair-haired child on her mother’s left, with Delphine, Jeanne, and Béatrice standing behind. The photograph had been taken in a park in Rouen; among the plane trees in the background an oblivious couple were strolling over the gravel. In the foreground at her father’s feet was the Fourmentiers’ small white dog.
She looked into the staring face of her father, the eyes dark and remote above the thick moustache. How hard he would find it to understand what she was doing, she thought. How little he had ever tried.